Starmer wants rethink on international law to tackle migration
43 minutes agoSam FrancisPolitical reporter
Sir Keir Starmer has said his government will look again at international law to meet the challenge of “mass migration”.
The prime minister gave the clearest sign yet the government is planning a major overhaul on the use of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) in immigration cases, but insisted he would not pull the UK out of existing treaties.
His comments came after his home secretary set out plans to tighten rules for migrants seeking indefinite leave to remain during a Labour Party conference focused on how to beat an insurgent Reform UK.
Sir Keir told Radio 4’s Today Programme “we need to look again at the interpretation” of a wide range of international laws by UK courts.
Sir Keir warned that laws must be “applied in the circumstances as they are now” before adding that countries were experiencing “mass migration in a way that we have not seen in previous years”.
To meet this new challenge “we need to look at again at the interpretation of some of these provisions, not tear them down”, he said.
On the issue of deportation, he was asked about the example of a Brazilian paedophile who successfully claimed he would be treated worse in a Brazilian prison than he would in a British prison.
The prime minister drew a line between deporting someone to “summary execution” and claims based on worse healthcare or prison conditions abroad.
“I believe that those genuinely fleeing persecution should be afforded asylum and that is a compassionate act,” he added.
Pressed for details about what was blocking deportations of foreign criminals, Sir Keir cited Articles 3 and 8 of the ECHR – which ban torture and protect the right to private and family life respectively.
“But it’s more than that,” he said, pointing to the UN’s Refugee Convention, Torture Convention and Convention on the Rights of the Child as potential barriers.
Ministers were already exploring ways to tighten the interpretation of some aspects of the ECHR to crack down on immigration.
In May, the government’s immigration white paper promised legislation to “clarify” how the right to a family life in European human rights law should apply to immigration cases.
Before being made foreign secretary, Yvette Cooper ordered home officials to look into how courts used laws that halted deportations on torture grounds.
Sir Keir’s comments come after a Labour conference dominated by efforts to confront Reform UK.
The prime minister used his keynote speech to cast Nigel Farage’s movement as practising the “politics of grievance” and to position Labour as the party of “tolerant, decent” patriotism.
He stopped short in the speech of repeating his attack on Reform’s deportation proposals as “racist” but vowed to fight racist rhetoric “with everything we have”.
Sir Keir has also spent the conference contending with a provocative challenge to his leadership by Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham who said Labour MPs had asked him all summer to return to Westminster and take over as prime minister.
Asked about internal challenges to his leadership, Sir Keir said he had “been underestimated every time” he had taken on a senior role.
Despite this, “I pushed through the barriers,” he said.
Sir Keir told the BBC: “I didn’t come into politics as some sort of popularity contest.
“I came in with one focus, which is changing my country for the better.
“I’m proud to be prime minister, getting on with that work.”
During a wide-ranging interview, Sir Keir also said it was “wrong” that thousands of young people remained out of work because of mental problems.
“I’m not saying you don’t and shouldn’t have benefits for mental health issues but I do think we need to examine this quite carefully,” he added.
“I say it because if you are on benefits, in your 20s, it is going to be extremely difficult to get off benefits for the rest of your life.”
Sign up for our Politics Essential newsletter to keep up with the inner workings of Westminster and beyond.